Welcome to my little corner of culinary delights.
I explained the importance and particulars of the grading system using a cookie contest for my example. I now wish to cover important responsibilities of the judges.
Every judge must be impartial. If the contest is not age-sensitive, then regrettably, a child contestant must be judged no differently than an adult. Professional cooks and bakers should never be allowed to compete against amateurs or beginners. Never judge by the appearance of the contestant. It is not a beauty contest.
Those who judge should be professionals. If a judge does not know what to look for, he may not be able to grade between subtle differences or evaluate the quality. Example: Is the texture too crumbly or not dry enough for a dunking cookie? Should a dessert cookie have more or less sugar and have a chewier texture? Should honey have been substituted in certain types of cookies? The list is ponderous.
One other very important aspect of judging a contest is to be able to tell the contestant what he did well and where he needs to improve. Be able to explain how to go about improving. The bottom line when this stage is reached is to encourage the contestant to not only improve but to never become discouraged. If the judge is unable to teach these necessities, he has no business judging the contest.
People enter contests because they have an above average interest. Such interests should be nurtured and directed along the right path. By caring and showing interest in their efforts, they will care to improve and do their very best for next time. If you take their work seriously, so will they. In the end, they should all feel like winners. After all, they have already won over those who did not compete.
I judged a cookie contest once. The grading sheet was poorly constructed. It was constructed more for fudge bars than for cookies. But, I was required to use it, notwithstanding. Because of that scoring system, I was unable to give a good score to a young child who should have won. For each contestant, I pointed out their good qualities and instructed each how to improve. For this young man, I confessed that I did not know what his final score would be. However, I added that he had great potential. And if he did not win, do not give up. He had many years ahead of him to be a great baker. I pray for his sake, that next time, he will be graded with a properly constructed grading sheet.
In summation I say this: To have a contest, in itself, presumes the contestants are very good at what they do. Otherwise, why have a contest? If, then, the contestants do quality work, it takes high quality judges to create the grading sheets in addition to being the best in the category they are judging. In other words, to judge baking contests, all judges should be great at baking.
Until next time, peace to all.